What Every CPA Needs to Know About Business Strategy (But Wasn't Taught)

By Joy Francis, CFO & AI Automation Strategist

Figure 1. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

Why do brilliant CPAs who can navigate complex tax codes and financial regulations struggle when clients ask strategic questions like "Should we expand?" or "How do we increase profitability?" The answer is simple: accounting education teaches you to record what happened, not how to shape what happens next.

After four decades in finance, including my transformation from a $100-a-week bookkeeper to CFO managing multimillion-dollar investments, I've learned that the gap between accounting knowledge and strategic thinking is where the greatest opportunities—and failures—occur. Let me share what every CPA needs to know about business strategy that wasn't covered in your accounting curriculum.

The Strategic Blind Spot in Accounting Education

Figure 2. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

Traditional accounting education focuses on historical reporting, compliance, and technical accuracy. These skills are essential, but they represent only half of what businesses need from their financial professionals. The other half—strategic thinking, forward-looking analysis, and business development guidance—is rarely taught in accounting programs.

When I was working as a bookkeeper for that small electronics shop, I thought my job was complete when I balanced the books and sent everything to our CPA. He'd return it on his letterhead with a $300 bill, and I naively thought, "I can do that." What I didn't understand then was the strategic thinking that separated a true financial leader from someone who just processed transactions.

According to the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), 78% of business owners want strategic advice from their CPAs, but only 34% feel their current accountant provides adequate strategic guidance (Association of International Certified Professional Accountants, "Client Expectations in Professional Services," 2023). This gap represents both a challenge and an enormous opportunity.

Strategic Thinking vs. Accounting Thinking

Figure 3. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

The fundamental difference between accounting thinking and strategic thinking lies in time orientation and purpose:

Accounting Thinking: What happened? Why did it happen? Is it accurate? Does it comply?
Strategic Thinking: What should happen? How can we make it happen? What are the risks and opportunities? How do we optimize for the future?

During my time at the real estate conglomerate, I experienced this shift firsthand. As a regional controller, I was focused on accurate reporting and compliance. But when I stepped into the CFO role during the 1980 recession—with prime rates hitting 21½ percent—I had to think strategically about survival and growth.

I developed systems that allowed our construction managers to remain profitable when competitors were failing. This wasn't about better bookkeeping; it was about strategic resource allocation, risk management, and forward-looking decision-making.

The Five Strategic Competencies Every CPA Needs

1. Market Analysis and Competitive Intelligence

Understanding your client's competitive landscape is crucial for strategic advice. This means analyzing market trends, competitor performance, and industry dynamics that impact financial decisions.

When I worked with the family insurance agency, I had to understand not just their financial statements, but their market position, competitive threats, and growth opportunities. The father's retirement planning wasn't just a tax

Figure 4. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

issue—it was a strategic succession challenge that required understanding the insurance industry's consolidation trends.

Research from McKinsey & Company shows that businesses with strong competitive intelligence capabilities outperform their peers by 20% in revenue growth (McKinsey & Company, "The Strategic Value of Market Intelligence," 2023). CPAs who can provide this perspective become indispensable strategic partners.

2. Financial Modeling and Scenario Planning

Strategic decisions require understanding potential outcomes under different scenarios. This goes far beyond basic budgeting to include sensitivity analysis, Monte Carlo simulations, and strategic option valuation.

During my work with the Southeast Michigan Venture Capital Group, I learned to evaluate business models under various scenarios. When I analyzed that young inventor's device for securing steel coils on

Figure 5. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

trucks, I had to model market penetration rates, manufacturing costs, and competitive responses. The financial projections weren't just numbers—they were strategic tools for decision-making.

The Harvard Business Review reports that companies using sophisticated financial modeling for strategic decisions achieve 15% higher returns on investment compared to those relying on basic financial analysis (Harvard Business Review, "Advanced Financial Modeling in Strategic Planning," 2023).

3. Value Chain Analysis

Figure 6. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

Understanding how value is created, delivered, and captured in your client's business is essential for strategic advice. This requires analyzing the entire business ecosystem, not just the financial statements.

When I was managing the construction portion of our real estate operations, I had to understand every step of the value chain—from land acquisition to final sale. The financial systems I implemented weren't just about tracking costs; they were about optimizing value creation at each stage of the process.

This holistic view enabled us to maintain profitability even during the worst economic conditions in decades. We weren't just managing expenses; we were strategically positioning the entire value chain for success.

4. Risk Assessment and Mitigation

Figure 7 .Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

Strategic thinking requires identifying, quantifying, and managing risks that could impact business performance. This goes beyond traditional audit risk to include market risk, operational risk, and strategic risk.

My experience with multiple sclerosis taught me about risk management in a personal context. When I was diagnosed in 2005, I had to strategically adapt my business model to accommodate physical limitations while maintaining service quality. This required identifying risks (travel limitations, fatigue), developing mitigation strategies (technology adoption, service delivery changes), and creating contingency plans.

According to the Risk Management Society, businesses with formal risk management processes led by financial professionals show 25% lower volatility in earnings and 18% higher long-term growth rates (Risk Management Society, "Strategic Risk Management Impact Study," 2023).

5. Performance Measurement and Optimization

Strategic CPAs must understand which metrics drive business success and how to optimize performance across multiple dimensions. This requires moving beyond traditional financial ratios to include operational, customer, and strategic metrics.

When I was teaching financial classes at Ford Motor Company, I learned that the most successful employees were those who understood how their individual performance connected

Figure 8. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

to overall business strategy. The same principle applies to business metrics—you need to understand the causal relationships between different performance indicators.

The Strategic Conversation Framework

Developing strategic thinking requires changing how you communicate with clients. Instead of just presenting financial results, you need to facilitate strategic conversations using a structured framework:

Situation Analysis: What's the current state of the business and market?
Strategic Options: What are the possible paths forward?
Impact Assessment: What are the financial

Figure 9. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

and strategic implications of each option?
Recommendation: What's the optimal course of action based on analysis?
Implementation Planning: How do we execute the chosen strategy?

When the problem loan officer at our lead bank called me to evaluate mortgage purchases worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, he wasn't asking for accounting analysis—he was seeking strategic judgment. My ability to quickly assess the situation, analyze options, and provide clear recommendations earned his trust and demonstrated the value of strategic thinking.

Building Strategic Intuition

Strategic thinking isn't just analytical—it requires developing business intuition that comes from understanding patterns, relationships, and cause-and-effect dynamics across different business situations.

During my years working with venture capitalists, I developed pattern recognition skills that helped me quickly assess business opportunities. When I saw that young inventor refusing to put his patent into the business for a 51% ownership stake (extraordinary in venture capital), I recognized a pattern of entrepreneurs who prioritize control over growth—a strategic mistake that costs them long-term success.

The Technology Advantage in Strategic Analysis

Modern technology provides CPAs with unprecedented analytical capabilities for strategic thinking. Business intelligence tools, predictive analytics, and automated reporting systems can transform how you analyze and present strategic insights.

When I had to adapt my business model due to MS limitations, I learned that technology could enhance strategic service delivery. Virtual tools allowed me to serve more clients more efficiently while providing deeper analytical insights than traditional methods.

Common Strategic Mistakes CPAs Make

Figure 10. Created by Joy Francis using ChatGPT.

Mistake 1: Focusing on Cost Reduction Instead of Value Creation
Many CPAs default to cost-cutting recommendations because they're comfortable with expense analysis. Strategic thinking requires understanding how to create and capture value, not just reduce costs.

Mistake 2: Treating All Businesses the Same
Generic advice fails in strategic contexts. Each business has unique competitive dynamics, customer needs, and growth opportunities that require customized strategic approaches.

Mistake 3: Ignoring Market Context
Financial analysis without market context leads to poor strategic advice. You must understand industry trends, competitive dynamics, and customer behavior to provide valuable strategic guidance.

Mistake 4: Short-Term Thinking
Strategic decisions often require short-term sacrifices for long-term gains. CPAs trained in quarterly reporting cycles sometimes struggle with longer strategic time horizons.

Developing Your Strategic Capabilities

Building strategic thinking skills requires intentional development:

Study Business Strategy: Read strategy books, take courses, and learn frameworks used by management consultants and business schools.

Understand Industries: Develop deep knowledge of your clients' industries, including competitive dynamics, regulatory trends, and technological disruptions.

Practice Scenario Planning: Regularly create multiple scenarios for client situations and analyze the strategic implications of each.

Learn from Other Disciplines: Study marketing, operations, and organizational behavior to understand how different business functions create strategic value.

Seek Mentorship: Find experienced strategic advisors who can guide your development and provide feedback on your strategic thinking.

The Strategic Transformation Opportunity

The gap between traditional accounting services and strategic business advice represents one of the greatest opportunities in professional services today. Clients desperately need strategic guidance, and they prefer to get it from trusted financial advisors rather than expensive consultants.

But this transformation requires more than adding "strategic services" to your marketing materials. It requires fundamentally changing how you think about business problems and developing new capabilities that weren't taught in accounting school.

Remember what my mother always told me: "You can do anything if you set your mind to it." If a legally blind girl from Detroit could learn strategic thinking well enough to manage multimillion-dollar investments during economic crisis, you can certainly develop the strategic capabilities your clients need.

Your Strategic Journey Starts Now

The question isn't whether you need strategic thinking skills—the question is when you'll start developing them. Your clients are making strategic decisions with or without your input. Wouldn't you rather be the trusted advisor guiding those decisions?

The accounting profession is evolving from compliance-focused to strategy-focused. Those who make this transition will thrive; those who don't will be commoditized.

Your technical accounting skills are the foundation, but strategic thinking is what will differentiate you in the marketplace and create lasting value for your clients.

The strategic knowledge you weren't taught in school is learnable. The question is: are you ready to learn it?

Joy's journey from bookkeeper to CFO of a public company taught her that success isn't about being the smartest person in the room—it's about asking the right questions and having the courage to act on the answers. She now helps CPAs transform their practices by shifting from compliance to strategy.

Get your personalized Growth Pathway Playbook™. Book a 30-minute meeting. You’ll walk away with your own playbook to grow your business.

Works Cited

American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. "Client Expectations in Professional Services." AICPA & CIMA, 2023.

Harvard Business Review. "Advanced Financial Modeling in Strategic Planning." Harvard Business Review, 2023.

McKinsey & Company. "The Strategic Value of Market Intelligence." McKinsey & Company, 2023.

Risk Management Society. "Strategic Risk Management Impact Study." Risk Management Society, 2023.